"""LLM 传输健壮性层(从 core/loop.py 析出,2026-07-23)。 关注点:provider wire 层的瞬态故障检测与自愈 —— 与 agent 控制流(ReAct 循环 / 工具执行 / 熔断)正交。收在这里的东西回答同一个问题:「这一轮 LLM 响应能不能用, 不能用怎么救」: - 检测:畸形 arguments(JSON 解析失败)/ 必填 key 被吞(解析成功但键被流式乱序 吞掉)/ 空响应(tc 空且正文空)/ finish_reason - 留痕:三类故障各自 stdout + usage_events 双写(留痕绝不打断重试主路径) - 重试策略 robust_stream:首败即降级非流式(同轮流式失败强相关,provider 服务端 拼 tool_calls 绕开 delta 错位),salvage 可救则当轮继续 - usage/delta 提取:provider 差异归一 依赖注入纪律:取流的两条路径(collect_stream / nonstream)与 salvage 都以 callable 传入 —— AgentLoop 把 bound method 递进来,单测在实例上打桩即可,本模块不 import loop。 """ from __future__ import annotations import json from typing import Any, Callable, Dict, List, Optional, Tuple from .storage import record_empty_response, record_malformed_tool_call # ─────────────────────── delta / usage 提取 ─────────────────────── def extract_delta_content(chunk: Any) -> Optional[str]: """从 stream chunk 提 delta.content(文本片段)。chunk 形态 litellm ModelResponseStream: choices[0].delta.content。usage-only 收尾 chunk(没 choices / delta)返 None。 """ try: choices = getattr(chunk, "choices", None) if not choices: return None delta = getattr(choices[0], "delta", None) if delta is None: return None content = getattr(delta, "content", None) return content if content else None except Exception: return None def extract_delta_reasoning(chunk: Any) -> Optional[str]: """从 stream chunk 提 delta.reasoning_content(thinking 模型的推理片段)。 litellm 对多数 provider 归一到 delta.reasoning_content,个别只放 provider_specific_fields —— 两处都查。没有则返 None(非 thinking 模型零开销)。 """ try: choices = getattr(chunk, "choices", None) if not choices: return None delta = getattr(choices[0], "delta", None) if delta is None: return None rc = getattr(delta, "reasoning_content", None) if not rc: psf = getattr(delta, "provider_specific_fields", None) or {} rc = psf.get("reasoning_content") if isinstance(psf, dict) else None return rc if rc else None except Exception: return None def usage_to_dict(usage: Any) -> dict: if not usage: return {} if hasattr(usage, "model_dump"): usage = usage.model_dump() elif hasattr(usage, "dict"): usage = usage.dict() if isinstance(usage, dict): return usage return {} def extract_usage_details(usage: Any) -> dict: """从 provider usage 提取统一 token 明细。 DeepSeek 直接给 prompt_cache_hit_tokens / prompt_cache_miss_tokens; OpenAI 风格把 cached tokens 放在 prompt_tokens_details.cached_tokens。 """ data = usage_to_dict(usage) prompt_details = data.get("prompt_tokens_details") or {} completion_details = data.get("completion_tokens_details") or {} if not isinstance(prompt_details, dict): prompt_details = {} if not isinstance(completion_details, dict): completion_details = {} cache_hit = ( data.get("prompt_cache_hit_tokens") or prompt_details.get("cached_tokens") or 0 ) cache_miss = data.get("prompt_cache_miss_tokens") or 0 return { "tokens_in": int(data.get("prompt_tokens") or 0), "tokens_out": int(data.get("completion_tokens") or 0), "cache_hit_tokens": int(cache_hit or 0), "cache_miss_tokens": int(cache_miss or 0), "reasoning_tokens": int(completion_details.get("reasoning_tokens") or 0), } def extract_usage(usage: Any) -> Tuple[int, int]: """从 litellm response.usage 提 (prompt_tokens, completion_tokens)。""" details = extract_usage_details(usage) return details["tokens_in"], details["tokens_out"] # ─────────────────────── 故障检测 ─────────────────────── def malformed_tool_calls(response: Any) -> List[str]: """检出 arguments 损坏(JSON 解析不了)的 tool_call,返回 [name(len=N), ...]。 背景:deepseek-v4-flash 大参数工具调用偶发畸形 —— 流式 delta 错位把别处的内容 碎片粘到 arguments 开头(如 `].cells[1].merge(...{"path":...}`),拼回来后 JSON 解析直接失败。这种是上游瞬时抖动,不该入库污染上下文,调用方据此丢弃整轮重 roll。 只看「解析失败」;空字符串 / 合法空对象不算畸形(交给 executor 按缺参数处理)。 """ try: msg = response.choices[0].message except Exception: return [] bad: List[str] = [] for tc in (getattr(msg, "tool_calls", None) or []): raw = (getattr(tc.function, "arguments", None) or "").strip() if not raw: continue try: json.loads(raw) except (json.JSONDecodeError, ValueError): bad.append(f"{tc.function.name}(len={len(raw)})") return bad def toolcalls_partial_args( response: Any, required_by_tool: Dict[str, List[str]] ) -> List[Tuple[Any, str, List[str]]]: """检出「JSON 能解析、但必填 key 被吞掉」的畸形 tool_call。 背景(2026-07,失败面板 #3:edit `缺少必填参数 ['path']` 跨 13 task/9 用户):流式 arguments delta 乱序把某个键的值碎片瞬移拼进相邻字符串(实证 [1]:path 的 `.../gen_final_report_v2.py` 被吞进 old_str 尾部),独立的 `"path"` 键随之消失。这类 与 char-0 前缀畸形的关键区别是 **JSON parse 成功** → 既不命中 `malformed_tool_calls` (只抓 parse 失败)、salvage 也救不了(parse-to-end/key 白名单对合法但错位无能),一路 漏到 executor 才在语义层报「缺必填参数」,回 [Error] 喂回模型 → 再拼再乱序,反复烧。 判据(窄,避免误伤模型真漏参):解析为**非空 dict** 且 **至少一个必填 key 在场**同时 **至少一个必填 key 缺失**(即 0 < len(missing) < len(required))。空 `{}` / 必填全缺 (纯垃圾/无关键)不算 —— 交给 executor + _RepeatGuard 现状处理。 返回 [(tc, name, missing_keys), ...]。 """ try: msg = response.choices[0].message except Exception: return [] out: List[Tuple[Any, str, List[str]]] = [] for tc in (getattr(msg, "tool_calls", None) or []): try: name = tc.function.name raw = (getattr(tc.function, "arguments", None) or "").strip() except Exception: continue if not raw: continue try: obj = json.loads(raw) except (json.JSONDecodeError, ValueError): continue # parse 失败归 malformed_tool_calls,不重复处理 if not isinstance(obj, dict) or not obj: continue required = required_by_tool.get(name) or [] if not required: continue missing = [k for k in required if k not in obj] if 0 < len(missing) < len(required): out.append((tc, name, missing)) return out def is_empty_response(response: Any) -> bool: """检出「空响应」:assistant 轮既无 tool_calls 又无正文(去空白后为空)。 背景(task 2a1bc25d 案):provider wire 偶发吐空 —— 截断流 / finish_reason 无内容 / 网关把 tool_use 漏成正文后又丢空,回来的这一轮 tool_calls 空且 content 空。run loop 见 tool_calls 空即当「模型答完」静默 done、返回空串,无报错、run_status=idle,与卡死 无法区分。故和畸形同类对待:丢弃本轮走非流式重试。 注意:纯 tool_call 轮(tc 非空、content 空)不算空响应 —— 那是正常的工具调用轮。 """ try: msg = response.choices[0].message except (AttributeError, IndexError, TypeError): return False if getattr(msg, "tool_calls", None): return False content = getattr(msg, "content", None) or "" return not content.strip() def finish_reason(response: Any) -> str: """取本轮 finish_reason(取不到返 "")。length=达输出上限被截断,与 wire 吐空区分开: 截断是我方输出预算/推理失控(如 GLM thinking 烧穿),同上下文重试无效。""" try: return getattr(response.choices[0], "finish_reason", "") or "" except (AttributeError, IndexError, TypeError): return "" # ─────────────────────── 故障留痕(stdout + usage_events 双写,静默失败)─────────────────────── def log_partial_args( task_id: Any, user_id: Any, model_profile: str, partial: List[Tuple[Any, str, List[str]]], response: Any, ) -> None: """必填 key 被吞的畸形留痕:与 log_malformed_args 对称,进 usage_events(kind= tool_malformed),error 签名固定为 `missing required keys [...]` —— 在失败面板里和 char-0 型(`Expecting value`)、executor 的「缺必填参数」区分开,便于统计这条新裂缝。 任何一路失败都静默,绝不打断重试主路径。""" try: usage = extract_usage_details(getattr(response, "usage", None)) for tc, name, missing in partial: raw = (getattr(tc.function, "arguments", None) or "") err = f"missing required keys {missing}" print( f"[malformed:partial] task={task_id} tool={name} len={len(raw)} " f"{err} head={ascii(raw[:300])} tail={ascii(raw[-300:])}", flush=True, ) try: record_malformed_tool_call( task_id=task_id, user_id=user_id, model_profile=model_profile, tool=name, arg_len=len(raw), error=err, head=raw[:300], tail=raw[-300:], tokens_in=usage["tokens_in"], tokens_out=usage["tokens_out"], ) except Exception: pass except Exception: pass def log_empty_response( task_id: Any, user_id: Any, model_profile: str, response: Any, attempt: int, finish: str = "", ) -> None: """空响应留痕:stdout + usage_events(kind=empty_response)双写,任何一路失败都静默。 与 log_malformed_args 对称:空响应轮同样整轮丢弃、messages 无痕,这里是唯一留痕 —— 供事后定性(哪个模型档在吐空)与「工具失败聚集」面板第四段聚合。留痕绝不能反过来打断 重试主路径(单测无 DB 时 record_* 落库失败也吞掉)。 """ try: usage = extract_usage_details(getattr(response, "usage", None)) print( f"[empty_response] task={task_id} mp={model_profile} attempt={attempt} " f"finish={finish or '?'} tok={usage['tokens_in']}/{usage['tokens_out']}", flush=True, ) try: record_empty_response( task_id=task_id, user_id=user_id, model_profile=model_profile, attempt=attempt, tokens_in=usage["tokens_in"], tokens_out=usage["tokens_out"], finish_reason=finish, ) except Exception: pass # DB 不可用(如单测无 DB)不影响 stdout 留痕与重试 except Exception: pass def log_malformed_args( task_id: Any, user_id: Any, model_profile: str, response: Any, ) -> None: """畸形 arguments 的首尾片段 + JSON 报错位置留痕:stdout + usage_events 双写。 畸形轮不 append/不记账,这里是唯一留痕 —— 用于事后定性损坏形态(provider 流式 delta 错位 vs 本地 stream_chunk_builder 拼接 bug),以及向 provider 报 case 取证。 stdout 片段过 ascii() 转义:日志消费端编码不可控(Windows dev 控制台 GBK 遇 emoji 会崩),转义后 grep '\\[malformed\\]' 拿到的内容可无损还原。DB 行(kind=tool_malformed, cost=0)喂 admin「工具失败聚集」面板 + 巡检邮件(core/toolfail.py),units 里 快照该轮真实 token 供估算浪费。任何一路失败都静默 —— 留痕绝不能反过来打断重试主路径。 """ try: msg = response.choices[0].message usage = extract_usage_details(getattr(response, "usage", None)) for tc in (getattr(msg, "tool_calls", None) or []): raw = (getattr(tc.function, "arguments", None) or "").strip() if not raw: continue try: json.loads(raw) except (json.JSONDecodeError, ValueError) as e: print( f"[malformed] task={task_id} tool={tc.function.name} " f"len={len(raw)} err={e} " f"head={ascii(raw[:300])} tail={ascii(raw[-300:])}", flush=True, ) try: record_malformed_tool_call( task_id=task_id, user_id=user_id, model_profile=model_profile, tool=tc.function.name, arg_len=len(raw), error=str(e), head=raw[:300], tail=raw[-300:], tokens_in=usage["tokens_in"], tokens_out=usage["tokens_out"], ) except Exception: pass # DB 不可用(如单测无 DB)不影响 stdout 留痕与重试 except Exception: pass # ─────────────────────── 重试策略 ─────────────────────── def robust_stream( *, collect_stream: Callable[[List[dict]], Tuple[Optional[Any], bool]], nonstream: Callable[[List[dict]], Optional[Any]], try_salvage: Callable[[Any], bool], llm_messages: List[dict], required_by_tool: Dict[str, List[str]], emit: Callable[[dict], None], llm_start_event: dict, task_id: Any, user_id: Any, model_profile: str, max_attempts: int, ) -> Tuple[Optional[Any], bool]: """拉一轮 LLM 并保证返回的 tool_call arguments 可解析。 返回 (response, cancelled_mid_stream): - 正常完结 → (response, False);response shape 与非流式 completion() 等价 - 中途 cancel → (None, True);已收 chunk 丢弃(非流式重试期间 cancel 同样) 畸形重试:deepseek v4 系(flash/pro 均实测踩过)大参数工具调用偶发把内容碎片 错位粘进 arguments,拼回后 JSON 解析失败。这种损坏一旦入库会被每轮重发、诱导 模型继续学坏(投毒级联)。故拼回后先校验 tool_call arguments 能否解析:不能 → 丢弃整轮(不 append/不记账,原始损坏片段打服务端日志留痕)并立刻降级非流式重试 (同轮流式失败强相关,重试不再走流式);全部尝试耗尽仍畸形则交给 executor 的 invalid-JSON 分支返错给模型。重试消耗的 token 不单独记账。 流式只试一次:实测(2026-07,task 716ed3be,deepseek-v4-pro)3~4k 字符中文长文 write 的流式重 roll 同轮连挂 3 次 —— 同轮失败强相关而非独立随机,首败即降级非流式, 历史数据里非流式兜底从未再畸形。 """ response = None for attempt in range(max_attempts): use_nonstream = attempt > 0 # 每个 attempt 重发 llm_start(stats 同一份):非流式重试完成前零 delta 事件, # 而 warn 事件会让前端把当前文字段定稿关闭 —— 不重发的话「思考中 · Ns」占位段 # 没人重建,页面静止到重试完成,与卡死无法区分。 emit(dict(llm_start_event)) if use_nonstream: response = nonstream(llm_messages) if response is None: # 非流式重试期间用户点了停止(线程级 poll,见 loop._nonstream_once) return None, True else: response, cancelled = collect_stream(llm_messages) if cancelled: return None, True bad = malformed_tool_calls(response) if not bad: # 空响应(tc 空且正文空):provider wire 吐空,和畸形同类瞬态故障 —— # 丢弃本轮走非流式重试(多数瞬态重发一次即好,用户无感),留痕供面板可见。 if is_empty_response(response): fr = finish_reason(response) log_empty_response( task_id, user_id, model_profile, response, attempt + 1, finish=fr, ) # length=达输出上限被截断(我方输出预算/推理烧穿,非网关 wire 吐空)—— # 同上下文重试大概率再撞,措辞据实区分,便于用户/日志判性质(治本在 # 模型档,如 GLM 已禁 thinking 免推理烧穿;这里保证可观测 + 不误导)。 truncated = fr == "length" emit({ "type": "warn", "msg": ( ("模型输出达上限被截断" if truncated else "模型返回空响应") + ",丢弃本轮" f"{'重试' if use_nonstream else ',改非流式重试'}" f" ({attempt + 1}/{max_attempts})" ), }) continue # 必填 key 被吞的畸形(parse 成功、salvage 无能):非流式重试(服务端一次拼好, # 绕开流式 delta 乱序)。耗尽尝试仍缺 → 落下面 return,交 executor 返「缺必填参数」 # 给模型(多为模型真漏参,不再空转)。 partial = toolcalls_partial_args(response, required_by_tool) if partial: log_partial_args(task_id, user_id, model_profile, partial, response) names = ", ".join(f"{n}(missing={m})" for _, n, m in partial) emit({ "type": "warn", "msg": ( f"工具调用必填参数被吞 {names},丢弃本轮" f"{'重试' if use_nonstream else ',改非流式重试'}" f" ({attempt + 1}/{max_attempts})" ), }) continue return response, False # 先尝试就地抢救:畸形是 char-0 垃圾前缀 + 尾部完好 JSON(定层已证 provider-wire), # 全部畸形 tool_call 都能抠出干净 JSON 才改写并当轮继续,省掉一次非流式重试; # 任一抠不出则一个都不动,原样走下面的丢弃 + 重试(零回退风险)。 if try_salvage(response): return response, False log_malformed_args(task_id, user_id, model_profile, response) emit({ "type": "warn", "msg": ( f"工具调用参数损坏 {bad},丢弃本轮" f"{'重试' if use_nonstream else ',改非流式重试'}" f" ({attempt + 1}/{max_attempts})" ), }) # 非流式重试仍畸形(理论极罕见):交还给 _execute_tool_call 的 invalid-JSON 分支 # 优雅返错给模型,而非在此死循环。 return response, False